Example suppose a serial section of 5% and 20 processors. Even with infinite number of processors, maximum speedup limited to 1f. This paper studies the speedup for multilevel parallel computing. Speedup predicted by gustafsonbarsiss law is called scaled speedup using the parallel computation as the starting point, rather than the sequential computation, it allows the prob lem size to be an increasing function of the number of pe s. Siam journal on scientific and statistical computing. On the other hand, a code that is 50% parallelizable will at best see a factor of 2 speedup. Given enough parallel work, this is the biggest barrier to getting desired speedup parallelism overheads include. The simplified fixedtime speedup is gustafsons scaled speedup. Executionspeedup3 parallel performance metrics speedup how much do we gain in. Parallel programming for multicore and cluster systems 17 4 8 12 16 20 4 8 12 16 20.
An expanded speedup model for the early phases of high performance computing cluster hpcc design matthew f. An expanded speedup model for the early phases of high. We return to some of the issues with deceptive speedup. Sen,p tn,1tpn,p an algorithm is scalable if there exists c0 with sen,p. Gustafsons law argues that a fourfold increase in computing power would instead lead to a similar increase in expectations of what the system will be capable of. This study leads to a better understanding of parallel processing. Example adding n numbers on an n processor hypercube p s t t s t s n, t p log n, log n n s. Parallel performance theory 1 ipcc at uo university of oregon. Thus the sequential part of the program is an inherent bottleneck blocking parallel speedup.
Scaled speedup factor the scaled speedup factor becomes called gustafson. Sec tion iii elaborates when and how a superlinear speedup can be achieved for a parallel implementation of some algorithm. For other problems, it is shown that the scaled speedup curve indicates that massively parallel computers will be useful even if the execution time is constrained. Speedup of a parallel computation is defined as sp ttp 2, where t is the sequential time of a problem and tp is the parallel time to solve the same problem using p processors.
Sometimes a speedup of more than a when using a processors is observed in parallel computing, which is called superlinear speedup. Parallel software an overview sciencedirect topics. Measuring parallel scaling performance documentation. Parallel computing performance metrics let tn,p be the time to solve a problem of size n using p processors speedup. With only 5% of computation being serial, maximum speedup is 20, irrespective of number of processors. For example, if queries usually take ten minutes to process in one cpu and running in parallel in more cpus reduces the time, then additional queries can run without introducing the contention that might occur were they to run concurrently.
We used a number of termsconcepts informally in class relying on intuitive explanations to understand them. Speedup predicted by gustafsonbarsiss law is called scaled speedup using the parallel computation as the starting point, rather than the sequential computation, it allows the problem size to be an increasing function of the number of pes a driving metaphor. A parallel graph partitioning algorithm to speed up the. Relative speedup and efficiency are larger than their abso. Another view on parallel speedup proceedings of the 1990.
But how does this scale when the number of processors. Request pdf on jan 1, 2011, jack dongarra and others published scaled. The simplified memorybounded speedup contains both amdahl. Dec, 2015 the scaled speedup curve is linear only if the isoef. Speedup small system elapsed timesingle machinelarge system elapsed time parallel machine speedup results in resource availability for other tasks. Speedup for multilevel parallel computing request pdf.
However, the speedup sometimes can reach far beyond the limited linear speedup, known as superlinear speedup, which means that the speedup is greater than the number of processors that are used. In strong scaling, a program is considered to scale linearly if the speedup in terms of work units completed per unit time is equal to the number of processing. In chapter 4, the author presents parallel programmers with the available programming languages and their nuances. Provide concrete definitions and examples of the following termsconcepts. Scalable problems and memorybounded speedup citeseerx. Parallel calculation of density of states of large scale cyclic polyacenes. Predicting and measuring parallel performance intel. Parallel programming for multi core and cluster systems. A speedup greater than p is possible only if each processing element spends less than time t s p solving the problem. Gustafsonbarsis scaled speedup is justified by imagining the parallel program being run on a serial processor.
Superlinear speedup comes from exceeding naively calculated speedup even after taking into account the communication process which is fading, but still this is the bottleneck. Nov 25, 20 scaleup and speedup scaleup in parallel systems database scaleup is the ability to keep the same performance levels response time when both workload transactions and resources cpu, memory increase proportionally. Introduction to parallel computing, university of oregon, ipcc. Parallel programming is an experimental dis cipline. Basically, we use larger systems with more processors to solve.
One possible reason for superlinear speedup in lowlevel. Gustafson proposed a fixed time concept which leads to scaled speedup for larger problem sizes. Scaleup and speedup advanced database management system. Ooad parallel computing scalability free 30day trial. Parallel processing an overview sciencedirect topics. Predicting and measuring parallel performance pdf 310kb. This study leads to a better under standing of parallel processing. Parallel computing chapter 7 performance and scalability. Parallel hardware and software systems allow us to solve problems demanding more resources than those provided by a single system and, at the same time, to reduce the time required to obtain a solution. Some reasons for speedup p efficiency 1 parallel computer has p times as much ram so higher fraction of program memory in ram instead of disk an important reason for using parallel computers parallel computer is solving slightly different, easier problem, or providing slightly different answer in developing parallel program a better algorithm. Abstractthe speedup is usually limited by two main laws in highperformance computing, that is, the amdahls and gustafsons laws.
Parallel programming for multicore and cluster systems 29 gustafsonbarsiss law begin with parallel execution time estimate sequential execution time to solve same problem problem size is an increasing function of p predicts scaled speedup spring 2020 csc 447. Example the serial runtime of multiplying two matrices of dimension n x n is t c n 3. Parallel performance tutorial tamu computer science people. Speedup can be as low as 0 the parallel program never terminates. The reliability wall for exascale supercomputing xuejun yang, member. Known as amdahls law, this formulation has been part of the computing. Actually, in addition to the serial fraction, the speedup obtained by. It is intended to provide only a very quick overview of the extensive and broad topic of parallel computing, as a leadin for the tutorials that follow it. Gustafson called his metric scaled speedup, because in the above expression sp is the ratio of the total, singleprocess execution time to the perprocess parallel execution time. Building parallel versions of software can enable applications to run a given data set in less time, run multiple data sets in a fixed amount of time, or run largescale data sets that are prohibitive with unthreaded software. The speedup measures the effectiveness of parallelization. The speedup limits in parallel executions are described in section ii.
To introduce you to doing independent study in parallel computing. A efficient and scalable partitioning algorithm is crucial for large scale distributed graph mining. Gabriel abstract the size and complexity of many scientific and enterpriselevel applications require a high degree of parallelization in order to produce outputs within an acceptable period of time. If the oneminute load time is acceptable to most users, then that is a starting point from which to increase the features and functions of the system. The algorithm first efficiently aggregates the large graph into a small weighted graph, and then makes a balance partitioning on the weighted graph based on. This study proposes a new metric for performance evaluation and leads to a better understanding of parallel. In this paper, we propose a novel parallel multilevel stepwise partitioning algorithm.
Speedup, in theory, should be upper bounded by p after all, we can only expect a pfold speedup if we use times as many resources. Asymptotic speedup is increased as the number of processors increases in high performance computing systems 1. Since parallelization overhead, is ignored, gustafsonbarsiss law may over estimate the speedup. Memorycache effects more processors typically also provide more memorycache. Two models of parallel speedup are considered, namely, fixedsize speedup and fixedtime speedup. Early parallel formulations of a assume that the graph is a tree, so that there is no need to keep a closed list to avoid duplicates. Example continued consider memoryconstrained scaled speedup. Sublinear superlinear sometimes superlinear speedups can be observed. Speedup ratio, s, and parallel efficiency, e, may be used. The simplified memorybounded speedup contains both amdahls law and gustafsons scaled speedup as its special cases. A speedup plot of speedup versus p is a standard graphic in most of the hpc literature, and is simultaneously one of the most useful and one of the most abused plots around.
This chapter concludes with flynns taxonomy and definitions of the common parallel algorithm performance measures. Total computation time decreases due to more pagecache hits. Examples of obtained superlinear speedup for high perfor mance algorithms are presented in section iv. This is the first tutorial in the livermore computing getting started workshop. To accompany the text introduction to parallel computing. If the numbers of parallel processors in a parallel computing system are fixed then speedup is usually an increasing function of the problem size. Amdahls law looks at serial computation and predicts how much faster it will be on multiple processors. Stefan edelkamp, stefan schrodl, in heuristic search, 2012. The goal in this case is to find a sweet spot that allows the computation to complete in a reasonable amount of time, yet does not waste too many cycles due to parallel overhead.
37 35 1331 944 33 202 1374 1366 1351 1029 1401 532 88 1232 1452 468 1063 1453 1300 1401 1214 499 1485 260 216 414 500 104 1098 1425